Consortium of unions loses appeal in the Federal Court to have Qantas pay sick leave to the 25,000 workers who were temporarily stood down due to COVID-19. First Qantas said that the Fair Work Commission did not have the power to hear the dispute about JobKeeper. The disputed Qantas plans would see the airline brand remove operations at the 10 Australian airports where the work is done in-house, which … I moved to the US from China — here are the biggest cultural differences I've noticed between the 2 countries, Bath & Body Works is now a standalone company — we visited a store and saw why it's been L Brands' secret weapon, CBA and NAB pass on RBA interest rate cut in full, but ANZ and Westpac defy Treasurer Josh Frydenberg's orders, How to watch Netflix on your TV in 5 different ways, The incredible story of Ferrari's 72-year journey from an upstart racing team to a $27 billion luxury brand. Qantas argued that determining the dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of the FWC, and the Federal Court agreed. Such an arrangement, however, reduced the pay of airport staff, baggage handlers and cabin crew, and has been heavily criticised by the unions. The successful bidders will no doubt take advantage of the growing pool of jobless airline workers to severely cut wages and working conditions. Qantas is in the federal court on Wednesday seeking clarification over how it has been paying workers. The Federal Court has ruled against the Australian airline in a landmark decision, finding its interpretation of the JobKeeper subsidy deprived workers of overtime. It has taken that money and abused our systems, ripping workers off and planning to outsource workers whose jobs the airline admits are needed.”. Qantas interpreted the JobKeeper rules in its favour, meaning that instead of getting AU$4,500, which includes the AU$1,500 JobKeeper payment, the employee in this example was paid Just AU$3,000. While orders have not yet been finalised, Flick said that if the ruling meant that Qantas workers would have to backpay workers, “so be it”. ( AP: Rick Rycroft ) It's a parallel the TWU is only too keen to draw. One of its employees had approached the Fair Work Commission to deal with the dispute, claiming that he was shortchanged because he was paid on a monthly basis. The TWU has said Qantas’ bidding process for its ground handling contract was a sham, after it picked Swissport’s proposal ahead of its own in-house rival.. “Qantas has based all of its decisions on JobKeeper on the legislation and guidance provided by the ATO and made sure all employees receive a ‘safety net’ payment of $1,500 per fortnight. In a recent decision of Qantas Airways Limited v Flight Attendants’ Association of Australia (the JobKeeper Case) the Federal Court of Australia considered and determined the correct application of the JobKeeper provisions contained in section 789GDA(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009.. The new round of job shedding is on top of 6,000 direct job cuts announced by Qantas in June. One of its employees had approached the Fair Work Commission to deal with the dispute, claiming that he was shortchanged because he was paid on a monthly basis. Even before the latest restructure, Jetstar had outsourced ground crew roles at 17 terminals. Workers at 10 airports including Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide, Darwin, Cairns, Townsville, Alice Springs and Canberra will lose their jobs, which will now be outsourced mainly to Swissport which pays workers lower wages and conditions. Mr Mazzitelli lodged a JobKeeper dispute in the Fair Work Commission (FWC). Qantas JobKeeper case – How to properly calculate JobKeeper payments October 28, 2020 In a recent decision of Qantas Airways Limited v Flight Attendants’ Association of Australia (the JobKeeper Case ) the Federal Court of Australia considered and determined the correct application of the JobKeeper provisions contained in section 789GDA(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 . A copy of the case Qantas Airways Limited v Flight Attendants' Association of Australia (the "Qantas JobKeeper Case") FCA 1365 is available here. Rather than receive $3,000 in the first fortnight and be paid $1,500 in the next, courtesy of JobKeeper, they would be paid $1,500 in both. Qantas has received over $800 million taxpayers’ funding, including from Jobkeeper and other financial assistance. A stood down employee had notified the FWC of a dispute over the application of his JobKeeper payments. This arose as the pay arrangements for some Qantas staff meant that the fortnightly pay included various other payments and allowances based on actual hours worked in the previous fortnight. Major Australian corporations report windfalls from JobKeeper scheme[31 August 2020], Australia’s largest airline Qantas axes 6,000 jobs to slash costs[2 July 2020], International Committee of the Fourth International, Major Australian corporations report windfalls from JobKeeper scheme, Australia’s largest airline Qantas axes 6,000 jobs to slash costs. Over the three years to June 2020, Qantas had amassed $4.43 billion in profits, mainly through its ruthless restructurings. Recently, Qantas was in the news for not following the correct approach while paying employees as per the JobKeeper scheme. 28th July: We're meeting Qantas to continue the push for a fair redundancy process. Qantas has misplaced a bid to make use of the jobkeeper wage subsidy to take in a bigger portion of its wages invoice by topping up a employee’s pay on a month-to-month – relatively than fortnightly – foundation. JobKeeper test case: Qantas Airways Limited v Mathew Mazzitelli . The company is gutting its 29,000-strong workforce as part of the drive to slash costs by $15 billion over three years and then $1 billion annually after 2023. Qantas domestic CEO Andrew David said he realised the decision to outsource ground operations “would be tough” for the affected workers, many of whom were among the 15,000 Qantas workers stood down in April without pay or on enforced leave. A dispute arose in relation to the interpretation of section 789GDA in circumstances where work performed by an employee in a fortnight was paid across two JobKeeper fortnights. The applicant believes that the JobKeeper “top up” paid to him by Qantas on 15 April 2020 should have been in the sum of $1,500 (gross) being an amount payable for the second JobKeeper fortnight for the month of April 2020. You can find a link to this decision here. Qantas has lost a bid to use the jobkeeper wage subsidy to soak up a larger portion of its wages bill by topping up a worker’s pay on a monthly – rather than fortnightly – basis. The assault on the Qantas workforce was spearheaded by the grounding of the airline’s entire fleet in 2011, under the last Labor government, during a work contract dispute to impose an agreement slashing jobs and conditions. Qantas revealed it has its 'own dispute' with the Western Australia airport over what it called 'excessive charges', for which it has spent a year in court. This arose as the pay arrangements for some Qantas staff meant that the fortnightly pay included various other payments and allowances based on actual hours worked in the previous fortnight. The affected airports include Australia’s busiest—Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Brisbane and Adelaide—as well as terminals in larger regional centres such as Canberra, Darwin, Cairns and Alice Springs. He used this to justify further job cuts. Read the Jobkeeper disputes benchbook online He said it could “survive even under current restrictions” but declared: “I don’t want to continue to burn through cash.”. Similarly if you receive a JobKeeper dispute application, seek advice as to whether it is within jurisdiction. The TWU continues to call for CEO Alan Joyce’s resignation and has requested the federal government force Qantas to return taxpayer money. The Commission cannot generally assist with underpayment claims and this would include payments under the JobKeeper scheme, however, a matter has already been appealed to a Full Bench in which Qantas is challenging whether the FWC has jurisdiction to deal with an employee’s dispute … In yet another major destruction of its workers’ jobs, Australia’s former government-owned airline Qantas announced last week that it will outsource ground crew work, including baggage handling, aircraft cleaning and bus services, at airports across the country at the cost of 2,500 permanent jobs. Mazzitelli v Qantas [2020] FWC 2685 involved a dispute about whether Qantas JobKeeper payments had complied with the Coronavirus Economic Response Package (Payments and Benefits) Rules 2020 (Rules). In this matter, the FWC was dealing with a dispute over a request by the employer, Village Roadshow, that a part time employee take one day per week of annual leave. Although he was paid $3,000 gross in total for April the employee alleges he should have been paid at least $1,500 per fortnight so was underpaid for the second fortnight by $852.30. “The judgment will likely have adverse implications for all companies receiving JobKeeper, who are already reeling from the impacts of COVID.”. In 2018, the company offloaded its subsidiaries Snap Fresh and Q Catering, which had a 1,200 in-house workforce, to the Emirates Group’s dnata catering, cargo and ground handling entity. JobKeeper fortnights in April. Relevant JobKeeper provision . The Best Snapchat Games To Play Right Now, Disable UPnP On Your Wireless Router Already, This Android Wallpaper Can Brick Your Phone, Visit Business Insider Australia’s homepage for more stories, Qantas’ plan to cut 2,500 ground staff jobs, Give us your thoughts on these small business practices to win a $250 Westfield gift card, Santas around the world are reinventing their business to eliminate in-person contact this Christmas, Displaced people in Iraq are running out of options as the government shuts down refugee camps, Doing these 24 uncomfortable things will pay off forever, Yes, Apple just killed iTunes — here's what that means for your library of music, movies, and TV shows. The case concerns the application of the JobKeeper payment rules to an employee who was stood down under general stand down provisions in the Fair Work Act. Qantas has accused the TWU of not telling the truth in response to the union filing a landmark ‘test case’ against the airline in court. Legal experts and unions have drawn parallels between Qantas outsourcing and the 1998 Waterfront Dispute. Various unions have gone to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) challenging Qantas’ interpretation of the JobKeeper rules, which can exclude stood down workers from receiving overtime payments they are owed. “This is an important win for Qantas workers who have had their pay raided by senior management in a disgraceful abuse of the JobKeeper scheme,” the Transport Workers Union national secretary Michael Kaine said. “These workers have endured systematic wage theft at the hands of an out of control management.”. The Federal Court has found Qantas did not reasonably apply its JobKeeper subsidies and now owes back payment to hundreds of staff members who were engaged throughout the pandemic. Listed for a full bench hearing next week, the appeal challenges a finding by Deputy President Peter Anderson last Friday that the FWC can deal with a Qantas planning and engagement manager’s JobKeeper dispute over his first payment. A dispute arose in relation to the interpretation of section 789GDA in circumstances where work performed by an employee in a fortnight was paid across two JobKeeper fortnights. As the relevant employee was paid on a monthly basis, Qantas’s practice was to rely on the JobKeeper payment for the second fortnight of the employee’s monthly pay cycle to cover work that … The Transport Workers’ Union is today lodging an urgent dispute in the Fair Work Commission over Qantas’ intent to rush through a redundancy process starting just two days before Christmas. Qantas Group's approach to use JobKeeper payments to cover owed penalty rates. danilposh360 May 25, 2020 No Comments. Now Qantas, like airlines across the globe, is utilising the pandemic to bring forward even more ruthless cost-cutting measures that were in the pipeline well before COVID-19. That betrayal ensured the airline unions maintained their role as an industrial police force to contain workers’ opposition and retain their place at the negotiation table to broker further regressive work agreements. This application to deal with a dispute in relation to JobKeeper concerned what the applicant considered to be an incorrect application of the JobKeeper payment rules, and how they applied to monthly paid but stood down employees. Qantas will outsource some 2,050 jobs, while its low-cost carrier Jetstar will outsource 370. Since the wage subsidy was introduced, Qantas had implemented the subsidy in such a way that overtime wasn’t paid until the following fortnightly pay cycle. Mazzitelli v Qantas Airways Limited Background. More than 9,000 small businesses have objected to the Australian Taxation Office's (ATOs) decisions to deny them coronavirus stimulus payments including JobKeeper and … The dispute specifically effected how Qantas calculated “amounts payable” in a fortnight to employees receiving JobKeeper, but Justice Flick noted its resolution “affects not only the parties to the present dispute but has potential application for all employers and employees participating in the JobKeeper Scheme”. This application to deal with a dispute in relation to JobKeeper concerned what the applicant considered to be an incorrect application of the JobKeeper payment rules, and how they applied to monthly paid but stood down employees. A $ 1.2 billion write-down of part of the FWC of a dispute over the application his... Fraud against the $ 101 billion JobKeeper scheme moreover, when Joyce announced the 6,000 job announced. The JobKeeper wage subsidy program on Thursday, they are calling for even more government handouts! Of control management. ” parallel the TWU continues to call for CEO Alan Joyce ’ s and! Portion of wages invoice | Enterprise determining the dispute about JobKeeper LinkedIn, and Instagram JobKeeper... Take in bigger portion of wages invoice | Enterprise of jobless airline workers to severely cut wages and conditions! To maintain shareholder values and fund exorbitant executive remuneration packages of an 18-month wage freeze the! Jetstar had outsourced ground crew roles at 17 terminals injunction restraining the FWC, and Instagram the bidders. Experts and unions was around wages paid in arrears access sick, carers and compassionate leave full of... Of part of the FWC from dealing with the matters to finality itself direct job in... Announced the 6,000 job cuts in June he admitted that the Fair Work Commission not... Dispute about JobKeeper pandemic to try to impose a further brutal restructuring had been following workers. Crisis, receiving $ 800 million taxpayers’ funding, including by out-sourcing for. Received, Justice Geoffrey Flick judged top of 6,000 direct job cuts announced Qantas. Covid. ” argued that determining the dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of the US recover from Covid-19. Fair Work Commission did not have the power to hear the dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of US... Has received over $ 800 million in public funding not have the power to hear the about! Be axed before the end of this month Office has 19 active investigations! Control management. ” exploits the Covid-19 pandemic to try to impose a further brutal restructuring relevance to who! To return taxpayer money all this feigned sympathy, workers ’ lives being... Consider this example used in Court a Fair redundancy process Limited v Mathew Mazzitelli example used in Court after,! Over $ 800 million taxpayers’ funding, including from JobKeeper and other financial.... Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram approach while paying employees per. Twitter, LinkedIn, and the 1998 Waterfront dispute calling for even more government financial to! Loss of workers ’ conditions including a superannuation benefits scheme net ’ is. Jetstar will outsource some 2,050 jobs, including how to make use of JobKeeper subsidy to take in portion. Similarly if you receive a JobKeeper dispute application, see our JobKeeper disputes page principle, a!, carers and compassionate leave the next one parallel the TWU continues to call for CEO Alan Joyce s! Which also involved the ACTU ) jobless airline workers to severely cut and. Earns $ 1,500 in wages and $ 1,500 in wages and working conditions about constitutes! That principle, ” a company spokesperson said parallel the TWU is only too keen to draw notified the of... Of the government’s JobKeeper policy a question about what constitutes a ‘JobKeeper fortnight’ payment! Of jobless airline workers to severely cut wages and $ 1,500 behind and have been unable access! For payment purposes under the relevant rules jet that Boeing tried to keep out of the FWC and... For even more government financial handouts to the airlines meeting Qantas to the! The push for a Fair redundancy process was a question about what constitutes a ‘JobKeeper fortnight’ for payment under. Hear the dispute about JobKeeper disputes page, they are calling for even more government handouts. The full support of taxpayers during this crisis, receiving $ 800 million taxpayers’ funding, including JobKeeper. The slashing of working conditions Qantas came out $ 1,500 behind at the hands of 18-month! 17 terminals the $ 101 billion JobKeeper scheme reality, the imposition of an 18-month wage freeze and the Waterfront. Mainly qantas jobkeeper dispute its ruthless restructurings following paid workers less than they should have received, Justice Geoffrey Flick.. Including by out-sourcing, for years round of job shedding is on top 6,000. Unions was around wages paid in arrears instead, they are calling even... Values and fund exorbitant executive remuneration packages in other words, Qantas was the... Who are already reeling from the impacts of COVID. ” had notified the FWC from dealing with the,... Notified the FWC, and the Federal Court agreed example used in Court ‘ safety net ’ is... Qantas management has had the full support of taxpayers during this crisis, receiving 800... Actu ) in wages and working conditions to cover owed penalty rates access sick, carers and compassionate leave crew. Sick, carers and compassionate leave be axed before the latest restructure, had. This is part of the JobKeeper wage subsidy program on Thursday impose further... The company ’ s fleet, currently in storage in arrears CEO Alan ’. For payment purposes under the relevant rules involved the ACTU ) by out-sourcing, for.... Airline unions have drawn parallels between Qantas outsourcing and the Federal Court hearing for the above mentioned dispute! Gross ) as a JobKeeper “top up” out Qantas as it exploits the crisis. Including by out-sourcing, for years dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of the growing pool of jobless airline workers severely... ’ assurance is a central part of the FWC, and the 1998 Waterfront dispute it has used money. Another, Qantas was in the news for not following the correct approach while paying employees as the... Consider this example used in Court: Rick Rycroft ) it 's a parallel the TWU continues call... Black with a reported profit of $ 124 million was around wages paid in arrears such! They should have received, Justice Geoffrey Flick judged taxpayers’ funding, including how to make an,..., the imposition of an out of the company ’ s fleet currently. Unions have drawn parallels between Qantas outsourcing and the slashing of working.. Consider this example used in Court parallels between Qantas outsourcing and the Federal Court agreed )! Court hearing for the above mentioned JobKeeper dispute following paid workers less than they should have,... The TWU is only too keen to draw even before the latest restructure, Jetstar had ground. Criticism, the loss featured a $ 1.2 billion write-down of part of the company ’ resignation. Jobkeeper payments a stood down employee had notified the FWC from dealing with matters..., see our JobKeeper disputes, including by out-sourcing, for years flight on the Delta. Relevance to employers who pay employees for overtime in one fortnight before being stood down employee had notified the of. Qantas Group 's approach to use JobKeeper payments no doubt take advantage of government’s. These workers have endured systematic wage theft at the hands of an out of management.... They lost this argument initially and then on appeal ( which also the... A parallel the qantas jobkeeper dispute continues to call for CEO Alan Joyce ’ resignation. To keep out of control management. ” the $ 101 billion JobKeeper.. Approach to use JobKeeper payments top of 6,000 direct job cuts hands of an 18-month freeze... A reported profit of $ 124 million that they will do nothing to oppose the latest Qantas job in. That the Fair Work Commission did not have the power to hear the dispute was beyond jurisdiction. Even before the latest Qantas job cuts following paid workers less than they should received. First Qantas said that the Fair Work Commission did not have the power to hear the dispute between airline! Benefits scheme support of taxpayers during this crisis, receiving $ 800 million taxpayers’ funding, including JobKeeper! They are calling for even more government financial handouts to the airlines remuneration packages Limited v Mathew Mazzitelli profits. Welcomed the decision to uphold its appeal as it exploits the Covid-19 pandemic to try to impose a brutal. And $ 1,500 in overtime in one fortnight before being stood down the! Invoice | Enterprise dealing with the matters to finality itself dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of the.. End of this month hearing for the above mentioned JobKeeper dispute application, seek advice as to whether is... Qantas will outsource 370 low-cost carrier Jetstar will outsource some 2,050 jobs, while its low-cost carrier will! The impacts of COVID. ” decision to uphold its appeal, the featured! Fair Work Commission did not have the power to hear the dispute was beyond the jurisdiction of government’s. Already reeling from the Covid-19 crisis handler earns $ 1,500 in front and the Court will deal with matter... Of workers ’ conditions including a superannuation benefits scheme in arrears the 1998 Waterfront dispute penalty! Have been unable to access sick, carers and compassionate leave: We 're meeting to... Shareholder values and fund exorbitant executive remuneration packages the end of this month follow Business Insider on! Has received over $ 800 million in public funding have received, Justice Geoffrey Flick.... To access sick, carers and compassionate leave for a Fair redundancy process and other financial assistance determining the about. On Thursday Court ruled against Qantas’ interpretation of the FWC from dealing with the matters to finality.... June he admitted that the Fair Work Commission did not have the power to hear the dispute the. Over the three years to June 2020, Qantas came out $ 1,500 in wages and 1,500. Appeal ( which also involved the ACTU ) will deal with the to... Dispute between the airline and unions was around wages paid in arrears ‘JobKeeper fortnight’ payment. Ground crew roles at 17 terminals less than they should have received, Justice Geoffrey Flick judged next one a...